Friday, 19 September 2014

What expat nurses tell us about China's healthcare system

by Michael Woodhead
A survey of Chinese-trained nurses working in Australia has revealed some interesting insights into the role of nurses in the Chinese healthcare system. 

Three main themes emerge from the interviews with 28 Chinese nurses working in Australia carried out by Zhou Yunxian from the Zhejiang Chinese Medical University, Hangzhou. In Australia, Chinese nurses found they had more independence and responsibility than they did under China's more regimented and hierarchical hospital system. Chinese nurses said they felt uneasy about having to take the initiative in patient care rather than be given orders by a senior nurse or doctor.
"Generally speaking, nurses here are more independent. They don’t rely on doctors totally. They can have their own thoughts and make decisions on the caring of patients," said one nurse.

Demarcation of roles is obviously stronger in the Chinese system - the nurses working in Australia found it strange that there was open communication and equality between nurses and doctors in a western healthcare system. "I don’t know what they (local colleagues) are doing, chatting with doctors – a waste of time from my perspective," said one, who believed that nurses should concentrate on 'nurses work' and not get involved with doctors.

Another theme that emerged was around the role of the nurse and their scope of practice. In China, nurses often saw themselves more as clerks and technicians fixing up IV lines rather than patient-oriented 'hands on' nurses. Chinese nurses were horrified to find that in Australian hospitals they were expected to do 'dirty' manual work such as bathing patients or helping to feed them. "I feel too embarrassed to tell people (the fact)…If I tell my family that a nurse in Australia needs to shower the patient, I think even my family would find it very hard to accept," said one.

 This revealed that in China, manual work in hospitals is done by unqualified low-status 'care assistants', and personal help with feeding, toileting and bedding is the responsibility of the patient's family, not the nursing staff. Nurses from China also found it hard to adjust to the notion of a family leaving the care of a relative to 'the system' rather than taking personal responsibility - especially with the elderly and the way they are left in nursing homes.

A third theme that emerged was communication. In China, nurses expected to be given clear instructions about tasks from superiors, however they did not feel any obligation to communicate with patients or their families. Chinese nurses were surprised to find that in western hospitals, nurses were expected to be friendly and personal with patients, who they regarded as strangers. "Here every nurse calls everyone 'sweetie', 'love', things like that. It is totally different from us… I have never thought of addressing a patient so intimately. It is hard for us because we don’t feel this way," said one nurse.

Language and cultural differences also meant that Chinese nurses found their usual 'direct' style of communication appeared rude and imperious to westerners. They found it hard to be 'warm' and polite, believing this to be insincere. In contrast, Chinese nurses expected that their colleagues would become their workmates and were disappointed to find that westerners were out of the door at 5pm and not interested in networking. "Anyway, they (local colleagues) come when they are on duty and they leave when they finish the shift. In China, we are colleagues even after the work. We go out together, and then we become very good friends."

Although designed to investigate the problems of Chinese nurses adjusting to the western workplace, the study highlights many of the assumptions that underpin the Chinese health system

1 comment:

  1. Conference Series LLC Ltd welcomes you to attend World Nursing Annual Congress during February 26-27, 2019 in Osaka, Japan. You will hear about all the necessary topics related to the new updates in Nursing. Nursing World Congress 2019 will unite people who have an enthusiasm for various fields of nursing. All the accepted abstracts will be published and International Certificates with CPD and CME credits will be provided. Each abstract will receive a DOI number provided by Cross Ref
    We will provide good waiver on Group Registration.

    • All accepted abstracts will be published in the supporting journals of the conference and Conference Book Proceedings.
    • Each abstract will receive a DOI number provided by Cross Ref
    • Opportunity to conduct Workshop with your team members
    • One to One Interaction with Keynote Speakers, OCM and Eminent personalities for the future course of work.
    • Opportunity to chair a session.
    • Certification by the organizing committee.
    • Individual keynote Page will be created to get more visibility for your scientific research.
    • Huge Benefits on Group Registration.
    • If you want to attend with your research group you can avail Group Discount.
    • Abstract page and speaker page will be created in Google on your name.
    • Live Streaming of your presentation through our websites and YouTube.
    • Global networking: In transferring and exchanging Ideas
    • A Unique Opportunity for Advertisers and Sponsors at this International event
    • Meet Experts & Influencers Face to Face


Add a comment